City, School Board Discuss Compromise Street Garage
Mayor Josh Cohen asked the Anne Arundel County Board of Education for an official memorandum of understanding on the project, but for now he has to wait.
Officials from from Annapolis and the Anne Arundel County School Board are going to continue talking about the possibility of building of parking garage near Annapolis Elementary School.
But the project is just short of an official memorandum of understanding between the city and the school system that would allow the project to officially move forward.
The city wants to build a parking garage along Compromise Street partially where the public playground and a portion of the school’s play area currently stand.
The project quickly met with opposition from parents and residents who started a petition against the garage and to keep the playground as part of any project that proceeds.
City officials are hoping to cooperate with the school board and build the garage in conjunction with an upcoming renovation and expansion of the school.
The school board did not sign a memorandum, but instead agreed to continue to have staff members work with city officials.
Board President Patricia Nalley, along with several other members, said the students are their foremost concern—especially their safety.
The goal is for the two parties to meet again at the next school board meeting in two weeks to possibly sign a memorandum.
So, even though Mayor Josh Cohen left Wednesday’s school board meeting empty-handed, he said the discussion is moving in the right direction.
“This is the first time we formally sat down to discuss it,” Cohen said after the meeting. “Some of their concerns are spot on. Hopefully, we can address some of those concerns and come back in two weeks and get a memorandum of understanding.”
But that’s one of the last things the Annapolis Elementary Parent-Teacher Association wants to see. Sarah Williamson spoke to the board on behalf of the PTA, laying out a list of complaints and concerns, including safety and health issues, concerning the garage.
“We are incredulous that either the city or the board would believe that a large parking garage is a suitable neighbor for the only available outdoor play area of an elementary school,” Williamson said. “We beg you not to diminish the long-awaited positive impact of this revitalization on the children of Annapolis Elementary School. Please say no to the city’s proposal for a Compromise Street garage on Board of Education property."
Cohen said the plan for the garage is part of an effort to remove an undetermined number of parking spots from the City Dock area.
Still, the city does not have specific plans in place, though some ideas include the garage having retail on the ground floor along Compromise Street.
Cohen said one thing is certain: Whatever the plan, a “robust and adequate” playground must be a part of the project.
“We must work out a relationship that fits the city’s needs and the Board of Education’s needs,” he said during the meeting.
Alderman Sheila Finlayson, who also attended the school board meeting, echoed the mayor’s sentiments.
“The idea is that we satisfy everyone’s needs before we move forward,” she told the board.
Cohen said should the plan move forward the city would create a citizens’ stakeholders committee, including the PTA, business owners and historic preservation officials.
Board member Deborah Ritchie said regardless of whether the board signs a memorandum, it does not constitute an endorsement.
“It does not necessarily mean we support a parking structure,” she said.
Heather Macintosh
11:49 am on Thursday, February 16, 2012
Any solution that involves building a multi-story parking structure next to a school and reducing that school's tiny, urban play area is a bad solution. The kids at Amnapolis Elementary need more room to run around and play sports, not less. This project is a lose-lose for the school.
Paul C
3:16 pm on Thursday, February 16, 2012
If I'm not mistaken a percentage of the parking spaces at the Hillman Garage are handed out to City employees parking for free (or at a discounted rate) as part of their employment compensation package. Why not move them out to the outer garages? Or the stadium? They could take the shuttle! This way shoppers could use the Hillman Garage! Then the children can keep their playground! The city employees are getting the MOST convenient parking for free or at a reduced rate of I'm not mistaken. Does anyone in City Hall or local residents know how many Hillman parking passes are handled this way and what type of deal they get? If it’s a lot of free or reduced rate parking for City employees then this may be the right solution for the children and the limited green space remaining downtown.
Monica A. Jones
8:07 am on Friday, February 17, 2012
Right on, Paul!
Mary Grace Gallagher
2:00 pm on Friday, February 17, 2012
A new garage is not safe and it's not necessary! As I understand it, 50-80 spaces at Hillman are City of Annapolis-related (they are trying to phase it out for new employees). I think a much larger number of them are leased to city businesses, who use them as a perk for min-wage employees. Meanwhile, the entire state workforce is shuttling out to the stadium each day. The city can do better than this shoddy plan!
Heather Macintosh
2:37 pm on Friday, February 17, 2012
Also, when the renovations begin on Annapolis Elementary, (and the magical window for construction opens), the parking spots allotted to School Board employees will no longer be needed - the school board building is to become part of the new school. So, voila! There's even more space in the existing parking lot! Maybe we don't even NEED to build a parking garage! Put in meters and call it a day.
Janet Norman
5:37 pm on Friday, February 17, 2012
Its not only Annap Elem using the playground, bball court, and park, its all Annapolitans, St. Mary's students, visitors, etc. Ask if they promise to rebuild the basketball court (no). The current school lot is used by all the other Annapolis schools as a PTA fundraiser during Boat Shows, on a rotating basis. Mandate that City employees park at the Knighton lot to free up Hillman spaces, and we are done with the discussion. How about spending City Council time on including adequate public facilities ordinances (with school capacity) into the City regulations, so they are not jamming more development into closed school districts? Instead of looking at fabric swatches for the Market house and tearing down parks.....
Jennifer Troy
10:38 am on Thursday, February 23, 2012
Online Petition link:
http://www.change.org/petitions/save-the-annapolis-playground
Excellent comments here! There should be an extended conversation about parking options before anyone one considers taking away a playground that is used 365 days a year.
Peter Cane
3:30 pm on Monday, March 26, 2012
My comments and thoughts are here. Feel free to copy photos I post to use to fight the parking garage plan! http://petercanephotography.com/blog/